Book: Daughter of Smoke and Bone
Author: Laini Taylor
This was the last book on my list for my YALC Reading Challenge, one that I bought last summer but like all of the books I bought last summer, had been left languishing on my shelf for a year. My friend has strongly recommended this book to me as she loves Laini Taylor’s writing and I have heard a thousand and one amazing things about this book and series from around the blogosphere. So did I enjoy it? Well sort of. It started off really promising, with an awesome heroine, an amazing setting and an interesting mystery with Brimstone and the teeth. However it went off track in the second half of the book and even more so in the third when the romance came in and took over what could have been a really great book, plummeting what could have been a new favourite, to merely okay. It so irks me when romance takes over what could have been an amazing book! Here is a short synopsis of the book:
Errand requiring immediate attention. Come.
The note was on vellum, pierced by the talons of the almost-crow that delivered it. Karou read the message. ‘He never says please’, she sighed, but she gathered up her things.
When Brimstone called, she always came.
In general, Karou has managed to keep her two lives in balance. On the one hand, she’s a seventeen-year-old art student in Prague; on the other, errand-girl to a monstrous creature who is the closest thing she has to family. Raised half in our world, half in ‘Elsewhere’, she has never understood Brimstone’s dark work – buying teeth from hunters and murderers – nor how she came into his keeping. She is a secret even to herself, plagued by the sensation that she isn’t whole.
Now the doors to Elsewhere are closing, and Karou must choose between the safety of her human life and the dangers of a war-ravaged world that may hold the answers she has always sought.
The first half started off so promising! I loved Karou, she was smart, snarky, funny, slightly mysterious, everything I love in a protagonist. The Prague setting was incredible, especially Karou and her friend’s favourite restaurant Poison Kitchen, which I wish was a real place because it sounded so cool. There was humour, there was mystery with Brimstone and his chimaera and the whole teeth thing and getting to see Karou go to different places through the doors was pretty awesome. So all in all a great start. The writing was also really pretty without being overly purple. I was totally invested in this world of Prague and teeth and wishes (especially the whole wish thing that was really great), so even though the plot was moving slowly, I didn’t mind. There was also a whole mystery with black handprints on the doors being introduced which I was intrigued by. And we had Karou’s friend Zuzana who was just such a cute, small, snarky badass, and was a great friend to Karou despite her disappearing off all the time. All in all it was shaping up to be a great book.
Then came Akiva. And everything I loved about the book in the first half was gone. Instead of focusing on Karou and her Chimaera and Prague and Zuze, it became all about Akiva, who had as much personality as a damp squid and his lurrrrrrrrrrve for Karou, despite having only just met her! (Can we be done with the insta love already?) He was just such a cliche, perfectly handsome, mysterious but incredibly dull, like most YA love interests. We spent chapter after chapter with Akiva and Karou talking about how much they loved each other and all that fluffy stuff and I was like, where have my cool chimaera gone? Where are the doors and the teeth and the wishes and everything I loved about the first half? Suddenly the book had done a 180 and become another cliche YA romance.
The plot was also incredibly slow moving, when it was there at all. It felt like it couldn’t decide what it wanted to be, was it about Karou’s chimaera family and Brimstone and the teeth and wishes like in the first half? Or about Karou and Akiva’s love story? Or about the war between the angels and chimaera? It felt like the book kept chopping and changing and there was no real coherency between the three parts. I felt like Taylor maybe tried to put too much into this book and it didn’t really work, it would have worked better if she had stuck with perhaps one or two main plot threads, rather than over complicating it. The main mysteries seem to revolve around who Karou really is (it’s established early on that she’s not quite what she seems) and what Brimstone does with the teeth, both questions that aren’t answered until the last third, meanwhile you have to deal with Karou and Akiva being all moony with each other despite barely knowing each other.
I loved Brimstone and would have liked there to be a little more focus on him really as I found his teeth collecting and wishes far more interesting that Karou and Akiva’s “love story”.
I did like the world building and the mythology of the Chimaera/Seraph world, Eretz, but I think it suffered a little by essentially all being thrown into the third half, it would have been better if it had been spread out more throughout the story. Still it’s an interesting world that Taylor has created and I’d be intrigued to learn more in the next book.
I liked that the book had chapter titles, it’s such a small thing but it pleases me when authors do it, simply numbered chapters are kind of boring!
The part with Zuze’s marionette show was so cool, I wish people did things like that in real life, it would be awesome to see. I would have loved to have seen more of her and Mik, they seemed like they made a cute couple and I was actually more invested in their relationship than Karou and Akiva’s!
The whole flashback sequence in part three was very clunky. I understand why it was necessary in the overarching plot of the story, but I feel like the flashbacks could have been weaved into the story rather than having their own separate part, again it felt very disjointed. The writing also ended up becoming increasingly more and more purple as the book went on, at least for me. The only thing I liked about the third part was the masquerade bit as I am a sucker for a good masquerade!
The chapter lengths were mostly good, although they were sometimes a little long in the second half especially when there wasn’t much happening.
The end was incredibly anticlimactic, we had just been through this hundred page detour in order to find out who Karou was, we get this massive bit of information and then it just cuts off? I mean I get that you’ve got to get your readers interesting in reading a second book, but this felt like a lazy cliffhanger rather than a good one.
Overall, this book started decently enough, with an intriguing mystery but deteriorated in favour of a sub standard romance throughout the rest of the book. I’ll still read the second one as I’m interested in seeing what happened next and I did like the world that the author created, but I hope that romance is less of a focus in the next one!
My rating: 3.5/5
My next review will be of the second book in Samantha Shannon’s Bone Season series, The Mime Order.
Agree with you. I loved the first half of the book, but the second half with the love story was so lame.
Thanks! Yes, it’s a shame when a romance ruins what could have been a brilliant book.
I just finished writing my own review for this book and I 100% agree with pretty much everything you said! It took me a bit to warm up to Karou, but once she started doing her thing I was so invested in her. And then some boy comes along and steals her personality! I really hated the romance because Akiva has nothing going for him except that he’s wicked hot and broody. The last bit of the book in Eretz just lost me. I bought book 2 because I’m hoping it will get back on track, but I’m not so sure.
Also: “it became all about Akiva, who had as much personality as a damp squid” had me howling.
Glad to hear I’m not alone, I’ve heard so much praise for this book that I felt a bit weird when I didn’t love it as much as everyone else! I know, she was so awesome until Akiva turned up then suddenly it becomes all about him. I know, we really need to stop with this whole “mad hot and broody but nothing else” LI thing. Ha ha, glad to have made you laugh 🙂
Also, YALC!! I’ll be there too and am super excited 😀
Oh cool, hope I see you there!
That’s what I feel about this book as well. Thanks for sharing your honest opinion.
I TOTALLY agree that Akiva barely has a personality. And their relationship is something that I didn’t get at all. I am not a fan of insta love because it feels artificial and not really a “romance”. I feel like “romance” is the process of two people falling in love with each other, not when they are already in love.
I also had SUCH great expectations of this book in the first half. I kept on waiting for when it’s going to build up to this huge and awesome plot. When I flipped the page (on my Kindle) and it’s already the Acknowledgement section, I was shocked, because I literally thought there would be a LOT more. So I get what you mean when you say that the book ended on a lazy cliffhanger.
Haha I could go on and on… seems like I have enough to write my own review 🙂 (I’ve read this book a while ago so I don’t feel quite write posting one haha) I’m just glad that I found someone who feels similarly as I do 🙂 Great review!
No problem, that’s what I’m here for! Exactly, romance is the process, not the end result and insta love denies us getting to see that process and it’s lazy writing because it means you don’t have to explain WHY these characters love each other. And yes Akiva was so bland! Yes I had huge expectations of this book from the first half as well, but they never really materialised. I know I was quite surprised as well when I realised that was all we were getting. I’m glad I’m not the only one who feels this way too. Thank you!
You have an awesome blog! 🙂
Would you mind checking out my book reviews blog at https://elsbookreviews.blogspot.ca/ and possibly give it a follow? Super excited to read your posts!
Thanks! I’ll definitely check out your blog 🙂
Ah it was refreshing to read a take on this book that so clearly mimicked me own thoughts. I never bothered to read the rest of the series though I am open to potentially read some of the author’s other works. Great review matey!
x The Captain
Thanks! I’m glad someone else feels the same way 🙂